6587.jpg 6814Thumbnails6546
Author
Esther & Franck
Brass Gallery
Visits
28479
Rating score
no rate

4 comments

Add a comment

  • Jamesblair - Sunday 3 January 2016 01:50
    I see there is still some controversy over what to call these brasses.
    I do not agree that the term "Gypsy" is necessarily negative; many Gypsies are very proud of the name, though some do view it as derogatory. The generally accepted "PC" term nowadays is "Traveller", reflecting the fact that the modern travelling community comprises a number of diverse elements who share a common lifestyle. Travellers to whom I have shown examples of these hand made brasses have confirmed to me that their forbears did make them, and it only died out in the '50's, when motor vehicles supplanted the horse.
    Whether an individual brass was made by English Romany, Irish Traveller (tinker)or travellers with no origins in these groups is impossible to say, and is in any case immaterial: they remain a surviving part of the history and heritage of the travelling community.

    Therefore I would suggest we call them Traveller Brasses.
  • jbcherry - Thursday 7 January 2016 10:27
    Hi James
    I think you have missed my point, I have no opinion on what to call travellers and do not wish to get into that debate (nor is this the place).
    I have not said or implied the term 'Gypsy' is negative, please do not try and prove how PC you are by accusing me of crimes I have not committed.
    My point is that unless you have evidence that a specific brass was made by a traveller to assume it was, just because it is hand cut, is wrong. Even then, evidence that SOME such brasses were made by travellers does not mean they ALL were. Travellers do not have the monopoly on making things by hand and to assume so is offensive to the many other groups of skilled metalworkers. Assigning what is part of our common heritage to specific groups is as I said, at best, romantic tosh, at worst, racist.
  • Jamesblair - Monday 18 January 2016 01:12
    Jbcherry I do now see your point, and I agree that it is wrong to ascribe an item to a particular origin simply because it is hand made. Arguably, many brasses could be considered "hand made" in a sense, because both cast and stamped versions were often finished by hand.
  • jbcherry - Monday 18 January 2016 20:32
    James
    You are quit right, most decent brasses will have received some fettling and finishing "by hand". I think the term "hand cut" or "tinker" should be kept for just those brasses that have been cut from sheet by saw, drill and file, without the use of casting or press tools. There will always be problems imposing an artificial order on something as diverse as horse brasses, not least the case of royalty and award brasses where a cast emblem is attached to a stamped back plate!
    John